
How do you pray?
----
For the last 10 years or so I have prayed, almost daily, using a prayer book. I started out by using the Daily Office SSF, the prayer book of the Anglican Franciscan communities; then I tried Common Worship: Daily Prayer, first when it was trialled and then when it was eventually released; then I tried the Catholic Divine Office, or breviary, in its three expensive volumes and in its shorter Morning and Evening version. I have also used the Book of Common Prayer from time to time, both in its original form and in that which is included in Common Worship. All these different prayer books have helped me at different times to keep a discipline of daily prayer and to provide the words for me to say or read. But is this prayer?
During the last two years of ministerial training I have encountered all sorts of ways and methods of praying, from Quaker-style periods of silence to hands in the air, pop concert-like shenanigans. I have walked around labyrinths in silent contemplation and I've swayed to endless choruses with the help of Powerpoint. But is this prayer?
As an ordinand (one training for ordained ministry) I have to meet a 'mentor' within my diocese from time to time. We talk about how things are going, both on the training course and within parish church life. My mentor is an evangelical priest and he has never used a prayer book for his daily prayer. He will read a passage of Scripture, usually making his way slowly through a Gospel or Epistle, and then use that reading as a base or prompt for his own free prayer. That is how he prays every day. I have always been impressed with how easily he prays. At the end of each meeting he will pray for me, and using free prayer he will gather up all that we have been talking about and offer it to God.
I wonder whether my use of prayer books, which I read, have had an inhibiting effect upon my own ability to use free prayer. I am aware that within groups of people some are more comfortable with free prayer than others, and I wonder how much of that is to do with personality types and how much is to do with the long practice of reading set prayers.
The English theologian John Owen, who was ejected from the Church of England in 1662, along with hundreds of other priests, for refusing to use the Book of Common Prayer, has written at length about prayer.
He contends that written liturgical prayer can have a negative effect on real prayer. 'Having utterly lost the Spirit of grace and supplications, neglecting best of all his aids and assistances, and being void of all experience in their minds of the power and efficacy of prayer by virtue of them, they found it necessary by these means to set off and recommend their dead forms.'
He writes that written prayers 'will appease a natural conscience; outward forms and representations of things believed will please the fancy, and exercise the imagination; variety, frequent changes of modes, gestures, and postures, with a sort of prayer always beginning and ending, will entertain present thoughts and outward senses, so that men, finding themselves by these means greatly affected, may suppose that they pray very well when they do nothing less: for prayer, consisting in a holy exercise of faith, love, trust, and delight in God, acting themselves in the representation of our wills and desires unto him, through the aid and assistance of the Holy Ghost, may be absent, where all these are most effectually present.'
'No persons, no churches, are obliged, by virtue of any divine constitution, precept, or approved example, to confine themselves, in their public or private worship, unto set or humanly-devised forms of prayer.'
(Works, Vol. 4, p 244-8)
For Owen, it is the work of the Holy Spirit that enables us to pray.
'The Spirit of Christ reveals to us our own wants, that we may reveal them unto him' and that we 'are guided by the Spirit to make requests for those things unto God which it is his will they should desire.' Therefore inspired by the Spirit 'free prayer, unto them who have an ability for it, is more suited to the nature of the duty, and to Scripture commands and examples, than the use of any prescribed forms.'
All this is food for thought for me who is set in his ways of liturgical prayer but who would like to be able to use free prayer more effectively. How do you pray?